Astor Wine & Spirits

212-674-7500
www.astorwines.com
Member Reviews
Adam I've gotten some fantastic deals from these guys.  I almost don't even want to tell you about them (actually, hmmm, I won't... here....).  Transactions, shipping, and everything go off without a hitch.  Though the selection isn't super-broad, there's always a few unique bottles (and deals) hiding on this website to make it worth your while to check in every now-and-then. 
Whiskey Master List
The Stores List
The Bars List
The Online List