Old Fitzgerald, Very Old (bottled 1960)
Added on Sunday, Jan 25, 2009 at 09:55 PM
  Bottler: Stitzel-Weller
  Age: 8 yrs Type: American
  Vintage: 1952 Subtype: Bourbon
  ABV: 50.00 % Region: Kentucky
  Price: N/A Availability: Collectors Only
Bottled in Bond       Distilled Spring 1952       Bottled Fall 1960

Note: LAWS suspects that the samples tasted below may not be representative of the true, original flavor of this whisky.  We believe the excessive soapy flavors, combined with the age of the bottle, indicate that over time the whisky has undergone some chemical processes (transesterification, and specifically saponification) which introduced new, bad flavors into the whisky not intended by the distillers.  However, we have kept these notes publicly posted so that others may compare their experiences with our own, or learn from our notes and observations.
Member Ratings and Notes
Adam
 
Not a lot there in the nose.  The palate is medium-to-largely sweet, and good, with decent depth.  The finish is long, building, kinda nutty, and rather boozy.  Some soapy aspects join that boozyness, and that's what really hurts this bourbon.  It would be really good stuff if it didn't fall apart in the finish.  
Chris
 
N: Mild, with butterscotch and citrus
P: Big and flowery, then rich rancio.
F: Rich and creamy, but then a gnarly soapiness emerges that, like a turd in the punchbowl, ruins the whole party. 
Sku
 
Nose:  Lots of alcohol on the nose, some caramel, but mostly alcohol.
Palate:  Big oak notes with sweet corn, chewy mounthfeel, a bit of perfume going into the finish which is fairly perfumed.

A bit over oaked, but nice stuff. 

On now reviewing the other notes, I have to say I don't detect the excessive soapiness (except maybe a little of that type of scent that I'm labeling as perfume).  It may also be that this has opened up a bit with exposure to oxygen since Adam and Chris tried it.  I found it a bit over oaked, but altogether a decent Bourbon, though certainly not among the best Stitzel-Wellers I've had. 
Whiskey Master List
The Stores List
The Bars List
The Online List