I just had this for the first time head to head to head with the 10 year and the Ugie. This won out by a hair because it is so much more smooth and drinkable. The heat is displaced by smooth and easy sweetness and the earthy peat is tamed to be not so biting. Among the three botles the Ugie comes close and bang for your buck says the Ugie a well....but I think this wins out for quality in my book.
I've always felt the ANB was more delicate with smoother peat level compared to the oogie. I wasnt a big fan at first and preferred the bigger and more aggresive oogie so I used to do a 50/50 vatting of the two which works out really well. But the ANB really grew on me and I really like its toned down peat. Sad to see it go. B+/A-