Bruichladdich Legacy 3
Added on Wednesday, May 21, 2008 at 10:21 PM
  Bottler: OB
  Age: 35 yrs Type: Scotch
  Vintage: N/A Subtype: Single Malt
  ABV: 40.70 % Region: Islay
  Price: $450 Availability: Specialty Stores
Member Ratings and Notes
Adam
 
After tasting this quite a bit over a long period of time, I've grown to like it more.  It's a very tame number, with mainly big fruits and floral stuff going on.  The finish is too woody and eventually hurts the return glass.  But I do enjoy it.  B-/B  See old review below for how my tastes seem to have changed (Or did it change that much in the open bottle?  To note, I am rather obsessive about using Private Preserve in all of my whiskies.)

[Old Notes] Mr. McEwan, I'm not sure I understand what you were going for here.  I mean it's not bad.  It's just not that good.  Very straightforward, with a very mild sweetness and woodyness.  A dry, bitter finish.  Not a lot to say about this one, there's just not much going on.  Puzzling.  C+ 
Andy
 
Per my previous recollection I thought Mr. Herz was being harsh although I was never truly blown away.  On a re-taste, I thought the nose has a nice wood-in-a-damp-cellar air to it.  Unfortunately Mr. Herz was correct elsewhere.  This malt was weak and fleeting. There was an interesting sweet to bitter transition with a hint of what the nose covered, but the whole experience lasted one second and reminded me of scotch watered down to 20%.  Why this is highly rated I don't know.  Perhaps the other reviewers like weak scotch.  Drop any digit from the price and you'll have what I think it's worth. 
Chris
 

N:  Violets, glue, acetone, a little smoke.
P:  Big transformation from beginning to end of palate.  Nuts and earthy notes.   Light.
F:  Chocolate, dry oak.

Seems a bit unbalanced.

 
Fuji
 
Mostly green apples, paraffin wax and chalk on the nose and palate with licorice and citrus peel to the finish. 
Whiskey Master List
The Stores List
The Bars List
The Online List