Glengoyne Duncan's Choice
Added on Wednesday, May 14, 2008 at 05:36 PM
  Bottler: OB
  Age: 15 yrs Type: Scotch
  Vintage: 1989 Subtype: Single Malt
  ABV: 55.70 % Region: Highland
  Price: $200 Availability: Overseas Specialty
Glengoyne's "Choice" series comes from individual workers at Glengoyne picking their favorite casks for bottling. 

Distilled July 4th 1989  Bottled May 2005  350 Bottles
Cask 1204
Member Ratings and Notes
Andy
 

Looks like the dirty motor oil sample at the tire shop, but that's because it must have raped the sherry off the cask.  A nice sherry monster but it doesn't pack the complexity nor finish of Ewan's choice (sorry Duncan).

 2nd taste - A monster yes, but the brown sugar and kero syrupiness makes it so drinkable, I'll give it a B+

 
Chris
 
N:  Crazy big sherry, chocolate, and cherries
P:  Sherry monster.  Creamy chocolate thing going on sets it apart from the B+ pack.
F:  Long and yummy, brings ya back for more. 
Adam
 
Sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry sherry.

The closest I've ever come to drinking sherry -- a rich, thick, syrupy-sweet sherry -- without actually drinking sherry.  The lack of complexity here keeps the rating down, and the massively-sherried-ness needs something else to balance it.  But if you love an overwhelmingly sherried flavor, this will blow you away.  Perhaps the most monstrous sherry monster I've ever tried.  B+/A-
 
DW
 
Very dark whiskey, this has a strong sherry-vanilla nose.  Initially thick, similar to cough syrup. Rich, chewy, light chocolate, and sherry. However, those flavors dissapear and leave a flash of alcohol. Overall this was reasonably enjoyable, but the pieces just don't fit well together, and there are many better expressions of this style. 
Whiskey Master List
The Stores List
The Bars List
The Online List