It's a nice drinker and I'd happily quaff some any day. It's just overoaked, though not terribly so.
Back when this hit shelves, cask #5 was considering among LAWS to be a disappointment and a "don't buy." As I taste it now (April 2015), I keep thinking that if this were a new release, it would be celebrated on certain blogs and sold out within a week. Make of that what you will, but I say: strange days have found us.