N: Intense smoke, very medicinal, much sweeter on the nose than the 16 year with some berry notes and something a tad funky. Ah! Got it, its a very slight, almost undetectable wisp of sulfur (the good kind). P: The palate is actually much closer to the 16, slightly more oily, a bit less peaty (I'm tasting them side by side). Its more mellow, despite its younger age and higher abv. The 16 has a honey and heather aspect to it, however, that is missed here. F: Get a little bit of purple fruit in the finish, but the sherry cask influence is relatively mild. Well, I just finished both glasses and they are both damn fine malts.
Nose of smoke, iodine, hints of hickory bbq. Occasionally something putrid yet still inviting.
Palate is rather sweet and delivers more than advertised by the nose. Smokey with oranges, lemons, coffee hints. Water improves and brings out more sweetness. Smoke ramps up in the finish and takes over, peppery.
It's tasty, but I find it challenging to drink at length. For me, it's kind of over-the-top with the smoke and tar stuff. B/B-