Caol Ila 1984 Scott's Selection
Added on Monday, May 10, 2010 at 09:59 PM
  Bottler: Scott's Selection
  Age: 22 yrs Type: Scotch
  Vintage: 1984 Subtype: Single Malt
  ABV: 53.50 % Region: Islay
  Price: $220 Availability: Specialty Stores
1984/2006
Member Ratings and Notes
Andy
 

Nose:  Butterscotch on charcoal

Palate: This is a wierd one.  It's common for me to find a great malt with a disappointing finish.  Here the finish is everything. For the first second it's just plain faint charcoal.  Then exhale... magic.  The finish has everything a Port Ellen has (butterscotch,redhots, sweetness), on a base of fresh tar.

 

Yummy! B+/A- 

 
Adam
 

Nose of peat smoke and bubblegum. Palate of delicious peat smoke and bubblegum. Finish of more peat smoke and bubblegum. Yep, there ya go. But wow, I like this a lot! Massively drinkable for something so peaty. Excellent! It's just great how this maintains such superb drinkability while being massively peated.

 

(Note to Andy: although the finish does drop off quickly while adding nothing, that just makes this all the more drinkable for me, in the best of ways).

 
Fuji
 
The nose on this was very dark (tar and asphalt) mixed in with lots of smoke and peat. But there was also a sweet maltiness to it. I had a wood fire going while drinking this and it held its own. 
Whiskey Master List
The Stores List
The Bars List
The Online List