Brora 1972 Old Malt Cask "Brorageddon"
Added on Wednesday, Feb 17, 2010 at 09:56 PM
  Bottler: Douglas Laing
  Age: 30 yrs Type: Scotch
  Vintage: 1972 Subtype: Single Malt
  ABV: 50.80 % Region: Highland
  Price: N/A Availability: Collectors Only
Distilled March 1972       Bottled February 2003       Cask 983       201 Bottles
For the PLOWED Society
Member Ratings and Notes
Chris
 
N: Molasses, meaty BBQ, plum sauce, iodine, chocolate, and some peat still managing to emerge from that massive nose.   Deep sherry, very rich.
P: A thing unto itself, thick and syrupy, a peat n' sherry concoction melded together into something unique, rare, and absurdly good.  Big big big.
F: Lingers on the BBQ.  Bacon.
(And thanks Alan!)   <-- Notify the Serge Copycat Police! 
Andy
 
Tasted at a time unconducive to formal notes.  However, I'll never forget how awesome it was. 
Sku
 
The nose on this starts with a huge bang of fruity sherry flavors with fig and other fruit.  Massive complexity.  The palate is huge and beautiful with raisins and other dried fruit with mild peat in the background.  And peat grows into the finish in which it dances with the sherry. 

This was the eighth malt tasted in a Clynelish/Brora tasting and it just blew away the competition.  It's got big fruit and sherry flavors but tinges of peat and smoke; the interplay makes it extremely complex and enjoyable.  I want to be drinking it RIGHT NOW! 
 
Adam
 

The key to this whisky is its extreme drinkability despite the massive, massive flavors in here... not that huge flavors don't make something drinkable, but I think you know what I mean. The sherry is almost overpowering, and without the smokey aspects it would approach not-dimensional... but the phenols and other subtleties rocket this into A-range. Complexities especially reveal themselves upon lengthier drinking (as they always do), and this gets more excellent with more to say on every sip. Mostly a big sherry number with restrained smoke, big toffee, and maple-syrup candy -- particularly that maple-syrup candy is big in the finish.

 

We rarely drain a bottle start-to-finish at a meeting, and the fact that this one never stood a chance says a lot.  A/A- 

 
Dave
 
Unmistakable A.  It has already been said above so I have little to add.  So much of what everyone else describes I agree with.  There are few whiskies that I think would work really well with food, but this makes me want to try it with a rare rib-eye....great stuff. 
Whiskey Master List
The Stores List
The Bars List
The Online List