Compass Box Lady Luck
Added on Wednesday, Jan 20, 2010 at 08:15 PM
  Bottler: Compass Box
  Age: N/A Type: Scotch
  Vintage: N/A Subtype: Vatted Malt
  ABV: 46.00 % Region: Scotland
  Price: $166 Availability: Specialty Stores
A marriage of 2 casks of Caol Ila (1984 25yr and 1980 29yr) and one cask of Imperial (1995 14yr).  Not chillfiltered.
Member Ratings and Notes
Chris
 
N: Smells like old Islay (tasted blind my guess was Ardbeg, wrong!), a little glue, farminess, motor oil.
P: Sweet and oily, surprising light and with subtle smoke.
F: Citrus and finally some stronger peat in the finish.
I'm very curious what the component malts were like because the one cask of Imperial has really balanced out the two casks of Caol Ila.  Surprising and welcome. 
Dave
 
Nose is sweet fruits with nice apples and cherries.  Little peaty notes way in the background.  The palate has some nice peaty iodine things going on but not enough to make this a B range IMHO. 
Mike
 

N: Light peat, sweetness

 

P: Lemon water

 

F: Turns to salt water.  Really refreshing.  Makes me want some seafood.

 

 

 
JC
 
Cinny Minny,
Some peat,
My notes at the time...
Mystery meat. 
Adam
 
Nose has an immediately apparent smoke, a coal and tar type of it. Not overwhelming, just nicely present. Something mildly oceanic and salty too. The palate -- hey, this is nice. It's like the nose, generally smokey yet not a monster, and mildly sweet. There's a mild and elusive complexity going on here, a medium-deep brine alternating with the phenols. As it opens up, powdered-sugar sweetness moves closer to medium than mild. In the finish, salt moves to the forefront, particularly in the very end, and sticks around quite a while. There's a nice balance between the peat, wood, and sweeter stuff that keeps me coming back for more. This strikes me as a great whisky for an overcast but enjoyable day.  B/B+ 
Whiskey Master List
The Stores List
The Bars List
The Online List