Rosebank 1989 Murray McDavid
Added on Sunday, Jan 10, 2010 at 08:16 PM
  Bottler: Murray McDavid
  Age: 11 yrs Type: Scotch
  Vintage: 1989 Subtype: Single Malt
  ABV: 46.00 % Region: Lowland
  Price: N/A Availability: Collectors Only
Cask MM523.  Bottled in 2000.  Bottle in photo is 70cl, bottle tasted was 750ml US release.  Interestingly, a 10 year version was also released that had this same cask number.  Did they fill half and leave the rest in the cask for another year?
Member Ratings and Notes
Chris
 
N: Very bright nose, apples and melon on top of green wood.  Smells a bit like dry champagne.
P: Big fruity attack, very clean and light.
F: Gets tangy and stings the tongue for a surprisingly long time, fades on a light oak note.
Interesting.  I opened this bottle a few weeks ago and found some disagreeable notes (moldy wet paper) but those are no longer present.  Without them, this is a tasty and refreshing malt.  Enjoyable enough that I had a second glass!! 
Adam
 
Nose of pears, apples, traces of vinegar and sake. Palate is very fruity, rather sweet, with a strong undercurrent of spice. Something floral is in here too, though it's not great, like you're actually eating some sort of cheap girly perfume. Dries out in the finish and the oak becomes too strong. Initially this was quite tasty and very drinkable, but it gets woody and tiresome, shades of chewing on old woodchips, with something vaguely soapy too. As bad as those flaws sound, it's still drinkable and fine. 
Sku
 
Nose:  Light and fruity.
Palate:  Fruit monster, sweet and light with some corn syrupy sweetness, then malt.
Finish:  malty sweetness, almost Irish like.

Very nice, fruity malt.  B/B+ 
Whiskey Master List
The Stores List
The Bars List
The Online List